Toffee Banoffee Pie – The Stay At Home Chef

Forget everything you think you know about banoffee pie—this one takes it to the next level! We’ve added our own spin to the classic banoffee pie with toffee and our honey shortbread crust. If you’re looking for the perfect mash-up of ooey, gooey Dulce de Leche, a toffee crunch, and a silky layer of whipped cream, this is the pie you’ve been looking for (no Jedi mind tricks here—ha!).

Want more slices of pie in your life? Give our delicious banana cream pie or southern chess pie.

Our delicious recipe is a spin on the classic Banoffee pie, which traditionally combines bananas and dulce de leche in a digestive biscuit (or graham cracker) crust. Our version replaces the traditional crust with our honey shortbread crust. It tastes like a graham cracker with the texture of a more traditional pastry pie crust. As if that wasn’t delicious enough, we’ve added toffee to bring another layer of deliciousness.

Ingredient Notes

• Bananas: Make sure your bananas are ripe but firm. We’re looking for solid yellow bananas that have not started to develop spots. Overripe bananas can become too mushy in the pie.
• Dulce de Leche: Can be found at your local grocery store often found down the International Food aisle near the Latin America section.
• Toffee Bits: Find these down the baking aisle near the chocolate chips.
• Heavy Cream: This may also be labeled as heavy cream or heavy whipping cream – either works fine.

Crust Options

This recipe features our homemade shortbread pie crust. However, you always have other options. You can go traditional with a homemade graham cracker crust or purchase a pre-made one. You can also opt for a classic pastry crust, or store-bought options such as roll-out pie crusts or a frozen pie shell. This recipe is designed for a standard 9-inch pie crust, so just be sure to bake the crust ahead of time according to the package instructions, as the filling doesn’t require baking.

Finishing Touches

For a gorgeous finish, spread the whipped cream evenly over the pie using a spatula or the back of a spoon. You can create smooth, elegant swirls or rustic peaks for a homemade look. Garnish with additional toffee bits or freshly grated chocolate shavings for an elegant look and added taste.